Epic Web Studios
Epic Insights
Edition 35  ·  Sep 1, 2026

Four AIs, One Business, Four Different Answers

Last week we asked Google's Gemini and Google's AI Overviews the same question about the same chiropractic clinic, in the same hour. Gemini named the clinic in every single answer. AI Overviews didn't mention it once. Same company, same question, same afternoon.


The Big Story

We Ran the Same Question Past Four AIs. They Disagreed.

Here's what we actually ran. One chiropractic clinic, four AI systems, same afternoon, ten questions a real patient might type. We use Local Falcon for this, which checks how often a business gets named in the answer across a grid of points around the office.

The results don't agree with each other. Not a little. On the phrase "chiropractor [city]" Gemini named the clinic in every single answer. Google's AI Overviews named it in none. Ask what an adjustment costs and AI Overviews had them in about two thirds of answers while Google's own AI Mode had them in under one percent. On "chiropractor near me" ChatGPT never mentioned them at all, and AI Mode had them in almost half.

So there's no such thing as your AI ranking. There are four of them, they move independently, and a vendor who shows you one number is showing you a quarter of the picture.

But one line in that table did something the others didn't. "Find a chiropractor near [landmark] open today" scored 97, 99, 96 and 96 across all four systems. The long, specific, awkwardly-worded question everybody agreed on. The short generic one is where the clinic kept disappearing.

Which is the least surprising finding in the world and the most useful. The pages that answer a real question, in the words somebody would actually say out loud, are the ones every system can use. That was true before any of this existed. It's just now measurable in four places at once.

What this means for your site
If somebody has told you that you're "doing well in AI," ask them which one. A single score hides the fact that you can be first on one system and absent on another for a question that means the same thing to a customer.

Your move: Pick one question a customer would actually ask out loud, in their words not yours. Ask it in ChatGPT, in Gemini, and in a Google search that returns an AI answer. Write down who gets named each time.


Quick Hits

The rest of the week, in bite-sized pieces

Labor Day Is Monday. Set Your Hours Today.
Google Business Profile lets you set special hours for a holiday, and if you skip it your normal hours stand. Somebody drives over, finds you closed, and Google starts collecting "temporarily closed" suggestions from strangers. Ninety seconds to prevent.
Your move: Open your Business Profile, set Labor Day hours for September 7, and while you're in there do Thanksgiving and Christmas so you're not back here in November.
Google Ads Can Add a Book Button You Never Set Up
Reserve with Google booking links have moved onto Search and Performance Max ads. If you've ever published an appointment link, Google can put a Book button on your ads without you turning anything on. Healthcare campaigns are excluded. Michel van Luijtelaar spotted it.
Your move: If you run Google Ads, click your own booking link today. If it dumps people on a generic homepage, that page is now sitting behind a paid button.
The Words On Your Profile Are the Words They Search
Your Google Business Profile services list is one of the few things you control outright, and it usually gets written once at setup and never touched. The scans above landed the same way: the clinic showed up for the phrases that matched how a patient talks, not the ones that matched industry vocabulary.
Your move: Read your services list like a customer would. Rewrite anything that uses your internal name for a thing instead of theirs.
On WordPress? Five Critical Flaws Landed Over the Weekend
Wordfence and Patchstack disclosed critical vulnerabilities in the Avada theme and in the WPMU DEV Dashboard, TranslatePress, Pods and GiveWP plugins, all rated 9.8 or higher. Several need a specific setup to be exploitable. This one's WordPress only, a small slice of what we manage.
Your move: If your site runs WordPress and uses any of those five, update to the current release this week. If we maintain your site, we're already on it.

Ask Epic

"Somebody pitched us on getting optimized for ChatGPT. Is that a real thing we should be buying?"

Real thing, yes. Something you should buy as a separate premium service, almost never.

We've been building for AI search for about two years now, well before it turned into a sales pitch, and here's the uncomfortable part for the people selling it: most of the work is the same work. Clear pages that answer real questions. Accurate hours and services. Current reviews. A profile that says what you actually do. You already own that, and paying a premium to have it redone isn't a strategy.

What's genuinely different is measurement. Until recently nobody could tell you whether an AI was naming your business or your competitor's, which is exactly why we run the scans in this edition. That's the part most vendors can't do.

So when somebody pitches you, ask them to show you a number, for a specific platform, for a specific question your customers ask. If they can't measure it, they can't improve it, and you're paying for a guess.


What Epic's doing for you this week
This week we're running AI visibility scans for managed clients across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's two AI surfaces, because checking one and calling it done clearly doesn't work. Those results land in your Client Center. We're also setting holiday hours and services on Google Business Profiles ahead of Monday, and finishing security patching on the WordPress sites we maintain.

Your 15-minute self-audit

Ask the Machines Yourself

1. Write down two versions of the same question. The short generic one a customer might type, and the long specific one they'd actually say out loud, including your neighborhood or a landmark.

2. Ask three different tools. ChatGPT, Gemini, and a plain Google search where an AI answer shows up. Same two questions in each.

3. Write down who got named. Not just whether you did, but who did instead. If the same competitor keeps turning up, go read their page for that question and see what they answered that you didn't.


Thanks for reading! Got questions? Ideas? I'm all ears. Share your thoughts with me and help shape future editions of Epic Insights.

— Kristy Freeman
Epic Web Studios
k.freeman@epicwebstudios.com

Talk to Epic →

Return to all